Descendants of James Rigby, schoolmaster, d. 1801The Rigbys of Pennsylvania
Religion
Section

Religion

An Anglican parish clerk married to a Quaker, for forty-five years. Almost everything this family can be shown to have done before 1800 was recorded by one church or the other.

James Rigby held a paid office in the Church of England for thirty-one years. His wife Hannah was a member of Concord Monthly Meeting for all but nine months of her adult life. They were married to each other from about 1757 until his death in 1801, and their household stood in both communions the whole time.

That is unusual enough to be worth stating plainly, and it has a practical consequence: the two record systems catch different things, and between them they catch almost everything we know. The Anglican vestry book gives us the office, the pew and the burial fees but no baptisms. The Quaker minutes give us the marriage — not by recording it, but by punishing it — the parentage, the death and the grave.

1758The Marriage That Both Churches Recorded, Differently

Friends married one another in meeting, before witnesses, with permission. Anglicans married before a priest. Hannah Brown did the second, and in the spring of 1758 Concord Monthly Meeting opened a case against her that ran nine months.

The formula the meeting used — married “by the Assistance of A Priest” — is doing something the clerk did not intend. In Quaker usage priest means a Church of England minister. It is the earliest evidence of James Rigby’s religion, two years before the vestry book at Marcus Hook records him as its clerk.

She was disowned in the spring, offered an acknowledgment in the autumn, and was restored by the first month of 1759 — then remained a member for sixty-five more years and was buried in the meeting’s ground. An acknowledgment was not a renunciation of the marriage. It was an admission of the manner of it.

1760–1791The Office on the Other Side

Two years after his wife’s case closed, James Rigby was chosen clerk of St Martin’s Church, Marcus Hook — at the meeting that gave the church its name. The clerk led the responses, set the psalm and kept the congregation’s part of the liturgy moving. It was a paid post, and he held it for about thirty-one years.

He did not live there. Marcus Hook is on the Delaware; he lived inland, eight to ten miles away, and he made that journey for three decades. In 1781 a county tax assessor, in a different jurisdiction, still identified him by the office: “James Rigby, Clk.”

He rented a third of pew 12 from 1790, moved to a share of pew 13 in 1794, and after that disappears from the rent roll. He died in 1801. The vestry met four weeks later and did not mention him.

A patternThree Generations of Wives, Read Out of Meeting

It happened three times, to three women marrying Rigby men.

The pattern, and how well each term is evidenced
YearWhoMeeting and causeStatus
1758Hannah Brown
m. James Rigby
Concord Monthly Meeting — married “by the Assistance of A Priest.” Disowned, acknowledged, restored.Documented
1796Elizabeth Harlan
m. Eli Rigby
Married “near Doe Run village” — not at a meeting. Suspected disownment; no minute yet found.⚠ Unproven
1829Lydia John
m. Seth Rigby
Chester Monthly Meeting — complaint for marriage by a magistrate, Philadelphia.Documented

The middle term is the one that would complete it, and it is the one we cannot yet prove. The test is specific: the women’s minutes for 1796–97 of whichever Chester County meeting covered West Marlborough and Doe Run — Bradford or London Grove. ⚠ There is a second Elizabeth Harlan at Nottingham Meeting the same year; check the township before believing a hit.

What supports the suspicion without proving it: the Concord burial register holds Hannah and no other Rigby at all, which says the later wives were not members when they died. And by 1844 the family had been received into Roxborough Methodism — out of both older churches within four generations.

The consequenceWhy There Are No Registers

For a family so thoroughly caught by two churches, one absence is glaring: there is no baptism, marriage or burial entry for James Rigby anywhere. That is not an accident of survival, and the reason is structural.

St Martin’s was a chapel of ease, not a parish. It had wardens, a vestry, a sexton and a clerk, but no minister of its own — the rector of St Paul’s, Chester rode down when he judged it right to, and a visiting minister entered his registers at his own church. Which is why a book kept faithfully from 1724 records pews, fences, lotteries and salaries and not one baptism.

And St Paul’s was not keeping them either. Its book contains a leaf ruled and headed “Marriages for ye year 1740” and left blank, and another headed “Burials for ye year 1738” and left blank. No entry of any kind survives there between 1745 and 1800.

One book would change that, and it has never been found. On 11 February 1831 the Rev. R. U. Morgan wrote on the index leaf of his register: “There is a Registry belonging to St Martin’s church, Marcus Hook, in which several marriages, Baptisms and Burials are recorded.” More on that →

Open in this section

  • Elizabeth Harlan’s disownment, 1796–97 — Bradford or London Grove women’s minutes. The missing middle of the pattern.
  • Morgan’s St Martin’s registry — attested in 1831, never located. Historical Society of Pennsylvania, the Genealogical Society of Pennsylvania, and the parish itself are all unasked.
  • The Concord minutes, transcribed in full — currently calendared from headings and sequence rather than read word for word.
  • Roxborough Methodism, 1844 — the generation that left both churches, and why.
  • Eli Rigby’s own affiliation — no membership record has been found for him in any communion, though he was buried in a Friends ground.